Effies
Australia

Effie Australia

Case History Database

Little Listings: How Mattel Broke a 98% Monopoly by Selling Toy Cars as Real Cars

Agency
Carsales, Thinkerbell
Client
Mattel
Awards
Bronze
Small Budget
Case Study
Summary
Facing LEGO's monopoly with a tight budget, Mattel could not win a traditional media war. Instead, we completely changed the battlefield. We bypassed the toy aisle and hijacked carsales.com.au. By treating our scale sets like real supercar inventory, complete with macro photography and expert motoring reviews, we reframed the product from toy to premium collectible. This highly contextual strategy delivered an incredible 96:1 media ROAS, captured 7.1% market share, generated $830,000 in rapid sales, and broke a six year retail lockout at Kmart.
Case study

Case studies are free for ACA members and Round Two Effie Judges. Email effies@adcouncil.org.au for your discount code.

All Educational Institutions wishing to access case studies are required to contact effies@adcouncil.org.au.

Credits
Brooke Wilson Group Business Director carsales
Steph Gratton Account Coordinator carsales
Shane Dawson Creative Director carsales
Marina Kran Commercial Solutions Director carsales
Ashlea Virag Commercial Solutions Specialist carsales
Margie Reid Chief Executive Officer Thinkerbell
Alvaro Bretel Tagliabue Executive Head Brand Thinker Thinkerbell
Ben Couzens Executive Creative Tinker Thinkerbell
Anna Craven Head Earned Thinker Thinkerbell
Adam Ferrier Chief Thinker Thinkerbell
Lesley Baker Executive Head Thinker Thinkerbell
Rhyen Ellis Lead Creative Tinker Thinkerbell
Jonathan Heath Head Creative Tinker Thinkerbell
Kyle Gradidge Head Thinker Thinkerbell
Jessica Sexton Lead Earned Thinker Thinkerbell
Alanna Jordon Lead Production Tinker Thinkerbell
Cam McMillan Lead Creative Tinker Thinkerbell
Amanda Kerr APAC Marketing Director Mattel
Chris Hillary Photographer Freelance
Daniel Kopel Filmographer Freelance

Effie Australia is proudly brought to you by Advertising Council Australia (ACA), the peak body for Australia’s leading agencies in the advertising industry.

VISIT ACA